Uncle Orson Reviews Everything
July 4, 2010
Every Day Is Special
First appeared in print in The Rhinoceros Times, Greensboro, NC.
Knight and Day, Airbender, Watching Parade Watchers
Tom Cruise and Cameron Diaz are two megastars whose luster has begun to fade with time.
Only a little -- they're still stars, and nobody's crying for what they get paid to make a movie.
But the promos for Knight and Day seemed to suggest a desperate kind of movie. Cruise plays
Roy Miller, a spy who has been accused of going rogue, when in fact he was playing by the book
and got framed. He is quite aware of the ongoing effort by those who framed him to get him
killed by the CIA.
Cameron Diaz plays June Havens, who grew up taking apart cars and putting them back together
again. She's on her way to her sister's wedding, and, because of her hurry and the heaviness of
her carry-on bag, Miller picks her out at the airport to be his "mule" to carry a small item
through security.
The promos made the rest of the movie seem like one long chase scene -- and it is, complete
with the standard trope of bad guys who always seem to miss and good guys who never do. In
fact they play with this movie cliche by having both Cruise and Diaz at various times simply
walk around in the open, bullets pinging all around them, mostly without a scratch.
But it isn't annoying, it's funny. Not scream-with-laughter funny. Endearingly funny.
Because despite the adventure/spy/thriller trappings, this is a romantic comedy -- and a good
one.
Take the wonderful comedy One Fine Day, and replace the efforts to juggle careers and
children's schedules when a single father and single mother inadvertently swap cellphones with
a constant effort by Cruise's character to keep Diaz's character from getting killed while staying
alive himself, and you have pretty much the same movie. And it's a good one.
The promos made Cruise's character look half insane. But in the movie, you have a context:
You know that he is frustrated with Diaz's utter failure to take any of his advice or heed any of
his warnings. So what comes across as manic in the trailers turns into comic exasperation, like a
parent talking to a teenager who has just wrecked the car. He's trying to be patient.
Meanwhile, she's trying to get some control over her own life as truly terrible things happen all
around her and almost happen to her. Just because I call this a romantic comedy doesn't mean
that the thriller aspects of the movie don't work. There are all kinds of spectacular gags and
stunts.
But there's something rather remarkable about all the stunts: They are never what the movie is
about. With The A-Team and Sherlock Holmes and Iron Man 2, the structure of the movie is to
progress from gag to gag, framing each one as if to say, "See what we were able to bring off?"
But in Knight and Day, the stunts -- every bit as dazzling -- are never what the scene or story is
about. Often they feel like an afterthought. They're background -- the characters and their
dilemmas and their growing attraction to each other and their issues of trust are always what the
movie is about.
In fact, many of the most spectacular stunts happen off camera. Instead of staying with Cruise as
he fights the bad guys, the camera stays with Diaz as she thinks she has made her way to safety
-- away from him. Only then she hears footsteps on the roof of the bus, or a motorcycle on the
other side of the freeway soars into the air and someone lands on her car roof, and she knows it's
him.
One of the running gags in the film is that when things are so dangerous that she's freaking out,
he drugs her and then takes her where he needs to go. Not only does this keep us from wasting
time on a meaningless excess of fights and chases, it also becomes one of the best signs of the
way their relationship develops.
Because these characters are truly fresh -- I haven't seen them before, or at least not in a movie
where things blow up. Cruise isn't phony-nonchalant like Bond -- he really has to concentrate
to do his feats of derring-do. Yet he does remain charmingly considerate of Diaz, always
thinking of her. If he happens to slip items into her purse or luggage from time to time, or say
things that offend her because she doesn't understand that he's playing down her importance to
bad guys who might think of taking her hostage, well, that's just part of the job.
My wife and I laughed out loud many times, and chuckled with enjoyment many times more.
We enjoyed the film from beginning to end.
I'm so afraid that the promos did a bad job of conveying what this movie really is, and that many
people who would love it are staying away. For instance, this is absolutely a women's film -- so
if you're a woman who is put off by all the explosions and chases and killings, come anyway.
It's no more shocking than, say, Charade, and has every bit as much romance.
Yet if you're a guy who is not at all interested in romance movies, go see it anyway -- the stunts
and chases really work, and it's funny.
Nobody has sex. There are a couple of kisses, a single F-word, some other rough language at
times of duress, and Diaz in a bikini is as close as they come to nudity. A few people die
spectacularly but there's no lingering camera work that seems to love the gore, as in so many
lesser movies.
And as for Cruise and Diaz, they have all the acting chops and all the charm they ever had. I'd
like to see them paired again.
In short, this is a movie for actual grownups -- not "adults," which in movie parlance usually
seems to mean "randy teenagers with no taste." If you want to treat yourself to a grownup spy-adventure-comedy-romance, this is the one to see.
*
I didn't see M. Night Shyamalan's feature version of the popular anime TV series The Last
Airbender. Airbender is one of the few animes that, when my 16-year-old is watching an
episode, I don't flee the room just to get away from the whiny chirpy voices. The story is quite
compelling.
So I understood completely when she and a few friends went to a midnight showing on the
morning of the feature film's release.
They were deeply disappointed. And not just because of petty annoyances. It's as if Shyamalan
thought the original series was so contemptible that he had to "save" it -- by jettisoning huge
sections of the original story and replacing them with hackneyed film school cliches.
There are two ways Hollywood makes movies based on books. One way is to treat the original
material with great respect, making sure that even when they have to change things to fit the
length requirements of film, they are true to the core story.
For examples of respectful film adaptation, think of how the Harry Potter series was treated, or
Emma Thompson's brilliant scripts for Sense and Sensibility and Nanny McPhee.
Then there's the other approach, which is to keep the title and the bits that the writer and director
happen to like, and then replace everything else with the worst sort of copycat filmmaking or
film school idiocy or whatever "trend" the studio executives fancy this film needs to reflect.
That's when you get disasters like Spielberg's Hook, the utterly nonsensical story changes Peter
Jackson made in his otherwise brilliant adaptation of Lord of the Rings, the shockingly dreadful
Ella Enchanted, and ... The Last Airbender.
It makes me want to give the filmmakers a good shaking and say: If you didn't want to film the
story, why did you spend all that money and use up the one chance we had to see it on the
screen?
I mean really, good as Lord of the Rings was, it wouldn't have cost a dime more to get rid of the
utter nonsense that Peter Jackson added about Arwen being near death, and his decision to gut
the film of Tolkien's real ending, the scouring of the shire, without which the movie has six
endings but none of them are good.
Here's a clue, since so many filmmakers -- especially Shyamalan -- seem to need one: When a
story works in book form -- I mean really works, so that readers remember it and reread it and
force friends to read it -- then chances are you can trust the story to work as it is.
It doesn't need saving, it doesn't need replacement, it needs translation.
It would also be nice if these rewriters of other people's work would take a humility pill and start
with this assumption: "I am making an adaptation of a story that was written by a better writer
than I am, and which I could never have come up with myself."
Such an assumption would hold them to the original story, making changes only where
absolutely required, and never messing with meaning -- the characters' motives and
relationships, the rules of the world, and, above all, the ending.
That's why, after every script of my novel Ender's Game written by somebody else, I have
wanted to sit down with everyone involved and ask them, quite sincerely, "Next time why don't
we try to make a movie out of Ender's Game, instead of coming up with yet another film school
exercise and pasting my book's title and characters' names into it?
"After all, the book has been doing fairly well for these twenty-five years, and it might be nice to
suppose that I actually knew what I was doing when I made it, and perhaps the writer ought to
have some idea of what a scene or sequence accomplishes before he throws it out and replaces it
with an ignorant one."
In other words, can we please hire Emma Thompson or Michael Goldenberg or Steve Kloves --
or at least a writer who understands how noble an achievement it is to faithfully translate a story
from one medium into another? These are writers who know how to make the sweeping changes
that are sometimes required while remaining absolutely true to the accomplishments of the
original version.
Not all of Shyamalan's changes in Last Airbender were wrong. For instance, as an Indian
himself, he was entitled to correct the bad American pronunciations of character names in the
original anime series with more correct ones.
But most of the changes were needless. They did not make the movie better. They made it
worse. Shyamalan's changes are so haphazard and meaningless that you have to think: He didn't
care at all about the original material.
If the result of his mangling of the story had been a movie that was good in its own right -- like
the mangling of Stephen King's The Shining -- then of course we can live with the result.
But that is not the case with The Last Airbender. With all of Shyamalan's changes, he took a
very good anime series and turned it into a forgettable third-rate feature.
We hear a lot about "poetic license," but in Shyamalan's case, his license ought to be revoked
for the crimes of Writing Under the Influence of Film School, or Directing With Arrogance.
*
This Fourth of July I happened to be in Provo, Utah. Now, Utah is not your average American
state: the biggest summer festival is not Independence Day, but rather Pioneer Day -- the 24th of
July, commemorating the entry of Brigham Young's band of pioneers into Salt Lake Valley in
1847. There's a huge parade in Salt Lake City; it's the event of the season.
Fifty miles to the south, poor little Provo, the third-largest city in the state, had no hope of
competing with Salt Lake City -- not when it's only a forty-five minute drive to see the Salt
Lake wingding. So they decided that since Salt Lake wasn't doing all that much about
Independence Day, Provo would specialize in that.
The result is that Provo is the Independence Day capital of Utah. There's a little irony in this,
since Utah is the only U.S. Territory the U.S. government actually declared war on, invaded, and
kept under military occupation for nearly forty years.
I mean, there was no love lost between most Utahns and the federal government, and while
Mormons believe the U.S. Constitution was inspired by God, they have often been very skeptical
about how well America's leaders have lived up to its principles.
But I guess Provo figures: Let bygones be bygones. Wave the flag and let the parade roll by.
For the past several years, space along the parade route has been so rare and precious that people
have been camping out -- that's right, pitching tents on the grass between sidewalk and curb or
even on the sidewalk itself -- for as many as three days before the parade. You can imagine the
way this makes Provo look like a city of vagrants and homeless people for days in advance of the
celebration.
On the other hand, because this is a Mormon town it is simply unthinkable that the parade could
be held on the Sabbath just because the Fourth happens to fall on a Sunday. Yet postponing it to
Monday (which is what they did) would mean that if the whole family went to church on Sunday
as they're supposed to, all the good Mormons would lose their parade-watching spaces and only
the heathens would have prime seating.
So the city banned camping on the street until 3 p.m. the night before the parade. (And on part of
the parade route, no one is allowed to set up until five a.m. on the day of the parade.) When the
legal hour arrived, those spaces filled up fast.
My wife and I happened to drive up and down University Avenue late on Sunday afternoon.
Having gone to high school and college in Utah Valley, we knew the streets well (and we
remember all the beautiful old houses that were torn down to make way for tacky gimcrack
apartment buildings).
But the array of humanity displayed along both sides of the street, along with their temporary
domiciles, their choice of activities to while away the hours, the meals and refreshments they
provided themselves with -- it was like attending a museum of American, or at least Utah,
culture.
There were the tents and pavilions that couldn't actually stand up (because it's both difficult and
illegal to drive pegs into concrete), so someone always had to sit there holding the poles.
There were families playing board games, children playing dress-up or having their own mini-parades, hands and faces smeared with melting ice cream, mini-barbecues and fullsize grills,
sleeping bags and bedrolls, and chaises longues bestrewn with people in swimsuits asleep with a
book on their faces, as if they thought they had been wafted to the Outer Banks (they should be
so lucky).
There were streetfront houses whose owners had set up chairs and awnings to provide shade and
were either inviting a lot of friends or charging money to strangers -- we couldn't quite tell
which.
And we realized that the real American parade went the other way. We should have been vying
for seats on the parade floats, so we could go down the street and admire or be amused by the
little mini-shows, ranging from six to sixty feet wide, that the spectators were putting on for the
enjoyment of the paraders.
Every Day Is Special
First appeared in print in The Rhinoceros Times, Greensboro, NC.
Thursday, July 8 -- American Horseback Day
Colonel John Nixon gave the first public reading of the Declaration of Independence on this
day in 1776, in Independence Square in Philadelphia.
*
In 1911, Nan Jan Aspinwall became the first woman to cross the US on horseback. She rode
into New York City carrying a letter to Mayor William Jay Gaynor from San Francisco mayor
Patrick Henry McCarthy, having left San Francisco on 1 September 1910. She covered 4,500
miles in 301 days. Now you can't even ride a horse across the freeway.
Friday, July 9 -- Argentine Independence Day
In 1958, an earthquake registering 8.3 on the Richter scale caused a massive landslide at the head
of Lituya Bay, Alaska, which in turn created a tsunami of 1,700 feet. A 300-foot wave
immediately followed, scouring bare about 4 to 5 square miles of land -- the highest tsunami in
recorded history.
*
Elias Howe, inventor of the sewing machine, was born on this day in 1918. When I was
growing up, most mothers expected to make clothes for their children, and the sight of patterns
laid out on fabric spread on the floor was a common one in American homes. Is anyone still
doing that? Because you have to stop it -- you're depriving Mexican and Bangladeshi workers
of their jobs!
Saturday, July 10 -- Clerihew Day
A clerihew is a kind of poem, named for journalist and author Edmund Clerihew Bentley, who
was born on this day in 1875. Clerihews are humorous biographical poems consisting of two
rhyming couplets of uneven length:
Sir Humphrey Davy
Abominated gravy.
He lived in the odium
Of having discovered sodium.
The people of Spain think Cervantes
Equal to half-a-dozen Dantes;
An opinion resented most bitterly
By the people of Italy.
Naturally, Clerihew Day is to be celebrated by writing one of your own. Just remember that
someone's name should be in the first line -- and preferably, but not necessarily, should supply
the first rhyme.
*
American painter James Abbot McNeill Whistler, born on this day in 1834, did not paint
"Whistler's Mother." He painted "Arrangement in Grey and Black: The Artist's Mother."
You can use that ridiculously finicky fact to annoy your friends.
Sunday, July 11 -- Alexander Hamilton Day
John Quincy Adams, sixth U.S. President, was born on this day in 1767. Like George W.
Bush, he was the son of a one-term President. He was elected in 1824 by the House of
Representatives, after the electoral college produced a toss-up election. All the candidates were
members of the Democratic-Republican Party, but in the House, Henry Clay threw his support
behind John Quincy Adams. Adams promptly made Clay secretary of state, provoking charges
of a "corrupt bargain," though such political dealing was perfectly normal at the time. Besides,
Adams and Clay agreed on almost everything -- and most of all on the fact that they both
detested Andrew Jackson and were glad of a chance to keep him from becoming President!
The Democratic-Republican Party divided after this election. Andrew Jackson led the
Democrats, and his opponents formed the Whig Party.
After his single term, Adams served eight terms in the House of Representatives -- the only
former President to serve in Congress. He considered his work in the House to be far more
important than anything he did as President -- and in those days, with a relatively weak
presidency, he was probably right.
*
On this day in 1804, U.S. Vice-President Aaron Burr shot and killed former Secretary of the
Treasury Alexander Hamilton in a duel. Excepting only George Washington, Hamilton was
perhaps the greatest statesman of the new republic. After writing most of the Federalist Papers
that laid the groundwork for the Constitution, he set up the American financial system -- over
the bitter opposition of Jefferson, whose ignorant ideas about economics would have kept
America a backwoods debtor nation.
Even during the Revolutionary War, Hamilton was Washington's most able aide, and one can
argue that Hamilton was the source of most (but not all) of Washington's most important and
successful policies as President. I highly recommend Ron Chernow's biography Alexander
Hamilton -- you can get the unabridged audiobook from Audible.com or the ebook for Kindle
from Amazon.
*
Bowdler's Day. Thomas Bowdler was born on this day in 1754. He gave up his medical
practice and created a ten-volume edition of Shakespeare with all the words and phrases
removed that "cannot with propriety be read aloud in a family." Cleaning up literature by
removing the dirty bits has since been called "bowdlerization," and it is generally regarded as a
Bad Thing. "Self-righteous" and "censorship" are words often linked with his project.
But much of the reason why Shakespeare's plays remained popular through that era was because
of Bowdler's edition and Charles and Mary Lamb's later Tales from Shakespeare -- a prose
adaptation that was likewise a version of Shakespeare that Victorian parents could read to their
children. Bowdler's versions did not keep people from reading the original versions if they
chose; instead, Bowdler introduced most of Shakespeare's genius to a much wider audience.
Since Shakespeare and the company of players he worked with always had their ear tuned to the
public tastes of the day, Shakespeare would certainly have written his plays a different way in a
different time. There is no reason except personal preference why these days the dirtiest possible
version of a story seems to be widely regarded as the only "authentic" or "artistic" one.
Monday, July 12 -- Good Neighbor Day
On this day in 1812, the United States invaded Canada at Windsor, Ontario.
*
In 1862, the Medal of Honor was authorized by the United States Congress.
Tuesday, July 13 -- Embrace Your Geekness Day
Today is the 80th anniversary of the World Cup of soccer. It was first held at Montevideo,
Uruguay, with 14 countries participating, and the home team, Uruguay, defeated Argentina by a
score of 4 to 2 to take the cup. (Only in America is it necessary to include the words "of soccer."
In the rest of the world, there is only one World Cup.)
Wednesday, July 14 -- Bastille Day
This is the national holiday in France commemorating the fall of the Bastille prison at the
beginning of the French Revolution in 1789. There were only seven inmates at the time, but the
Bastille had symbolic importance because it was known for holding political prisoners. Besides,
the revolutionaries wanted to seize the arsenal of weapons and ammunition stored there so they
could be better armed to resist the aristocracy's attempts to suppress them. If you can't afford to
go to Paris to dance in Bastille Square on Bastille Day Eve, and since we're not likely to have a
parade on the day itself, perhaps you can persuade the local fire department to open their doors
to large parties in celebration of the day, as is done in France. Or perhaps not.
*
Gerald R. Ford, the only non-elected Vice-President and President of the United States, was
born on this day in 1913 in Omaha; his birth name was "Leslie Lynch King, Jr.," but when his
divorced mother married Gerald R. Ford of Grand Rapids, Michigan, she started calling him
Gerald R. Ford, Jr. His name was not legally changed until 1935.
Named by Richard Nixon to replace the disgraced Spiro Agnew as Vice-President under the
terms of the new 25th Amendment to the Constitution, Ford ascended to the Presidency (and
named Nelson Rockefeller as the new Vice-President) after Richard Nixon's resignation. Ford's
pardon of Richard Nixon a month later was absolutely the right thing to do (and was definitely
not pre-arranged with Nixon), but it probably cost Ford the election of 1976, when he ran for
President in his own right.
*
Animator, producer, and director William Hanna was born on this day 100 years ago in
Melrose, New Mexico. With his partner Joe Barbera, he created such cartoon characters as
Tom and Jerry, Yogi Bear, Snagglepuss, and Magilla Gorilla. The team won seven Academy
Awards for Tom and Jerry cartoon shorts, and also created the first animated TV sitcom for
adults, The Flintstones (1960) and such favorites as The Jetsons, Scooby-Doo, Where Are You?,
and The Smurfs -- as well as the original feature-length animation of Charlotte's Web, which
remains a classic. Barbera did most of the writing; Hanna handled the directing end. In all, they
produced more than 3,000 half-hour shows and 150 television series.
*Based on information in Chase's Calendar of Events. See http://sn.im/chases. (Full URL:
http://www.mhprofessional.com/product.php?cat=3&isbn=0071627413)
|
|